The extremely tight pricing of the three year transaction due August 25 2003 has provoked sharply differing reactions among Yen bond players. On the one side, outside observers argue that a launch spread of 65bp over Yen-libor is at least 10 to 15bp too tight, while lead managers Nikko Salomon Smith Barney and Nomura respond that a combination of factors enabled the deal to sell out even though it might initially appear aggressive.